This week, the TMAM crew dives headfirst into the fun, freaky and sometimes surprisingly plausible world of conspiracy theories. From moon landings to musical icons, Bigfoot to body doubles, we're covering the greatest hits and the weirdest myths. We’re not here to prove or disprove anything! We're looking to laugh, learn and maybe question everything… just a little.
Cole’s got the science, Mecca’s got the CIA deep dives and Callie brings Bigfoot and pop culture flair. It's all in good fun—unless it’s not…!
So grab your tin foil hat (or don’t) and come spiral with us through some of the most legendary (and laughable) conspiracy theories out there.
10,000-Foot View of this Episode:
- More Than One Gunman? The JFK Theories That Won’t Die: We kick things off with the mother of all conspiracy theories: Was Oswald really the lone shooter? Cole, Mecca and Callie discuss CIA surveillance, Jack Ruby’s strange involvement, the mysterious "Umbrella Man," and how 65% of Americans don’t believe the official version. Mecca brings in newer details from recently declassified files and congressional efforts to uncover more.
- To the Moon…or Just to Science Class with Cole? Cole launches into a full-on cosmic TED Talk to debunk the moon landing hoax—complete with gravity breakdowns, star visibility, light refraction, and why crumpled flags aren't waving. It’s a crash course in space logic, while Callie and Mecca toss in pop culture skepticism, soundstage suspicion, and the lingering question: if the government lies, could they have faked this? (Spoiler: probably not. But it was fun to ask.)
- America’s Favorite Fuzzy Fugitive: Callie brings us into the woods with the ever-elusive Bigfoot. From Skunk Apes to tourist traps, they explore why this cryptid has remained a pop culture icon despite zero physical evidence. It’s fun, freaky, and just maybe—comforting?
- Elvis & Tupac…Did They Really Leave the Building? Mecca and Cole bring up persistent rumors that The King and Tupac faked their deaths. From typos on gravestones to YouTube “confessions,” they break down the lore, explore what keeps these myths alive and even touch on recent legal developments in Tupac’s case.
- The Doppelgänger Pop Princess: Did the real Avril Lavigne die in 2003 and get replaced by her body double “Melissa”? Callie explains the fan-led theory and why it spread—from changes in her voice and face to the evolution of her music. It’s absurd and weirdly compelling… like all great pop conspiracies!
- Why We Have a Love/Love Relationship with Conspiracies: The group steps back to ask the bigger question: why do people want to believe in conspiracy theories? They discuss pattern recognition, the need for control, brain-based bias and how shared belief builds community—even when it’s about Bigfoot. Cole reminds us we’re all just “big dumb monkeys,” but with internet access.
- Rigged Questions and Scripted Wins: When Game Shows Got Busted. Tucked among the big conspiracies, the crew unpacks the real-life cheating scandals of 1950s quiz shows like Twenty-One. Contestants were fed answers, ratings were rigged and America got a crash course in media manipulation—decades before reality TV made fakery feel normal.
Memorable Quotes:
- "There has been content that has come out that is just completely made up satirical content in relation to this and people will pick it up and run with it and use it like it is fact." – Cole
- “Our brains are really, really, really good at lying to us.” – Callie
- "I can assure you, birds are biological creatures. They are not robots." – Cole
- “The more I read, the more I am convinced that our brains lie to us on a regular basis. The older I get, the less I am convinced that there is a way to recognize what is truth.” – Mecca
- “We're educating our mother on the history of Tupac Shakur. I love this.” – Callie
- "I think I'm relieved because like I remember watching like History Channel Bigfoot shows growing up and just being absolutely terrified." – Cole
- “It just makes you discredit our government even more if that's really the truth.” – Mecca
- “If you tell the truth, you don't have to worry about keeping up with the lie. Just tell the freaking truth, guys.” – Callie
Resources Mentioned:
- "Devolution" by Max Brooks (affiliate link) is a fictional account of a Bigfoot massacre in the Pacific Northwest. Callie mentions the audiobook with full-cast narration (featuring Judy Greer and Jeff Daniels).
- "101 Essays That Will Change the Way You Think" by Brianna Wiest – Referenced by Callie during the psychology of belief section.
- Game Show Scandals of the 1950s – Learn more about the real-life quiz show cheating that rocked America, including the infamous Twenty-One scandal, at PBS: The American Experience – Quiz Show Scandal.
Whether you’re a hardcore skeptic, a secret believer or just here for the laughs, conspiracy theories remind us how much we all crave mystery, meaning and a little bit of magic in the mundane. From moon landings to music legends, they’re not just stories—we use them to explore trust, truth and the strange ways our brains try to make sense of the world. If something in this episode got you thinking (or spiraling), we want to hear about it! Share your favorite conspiracy theory—or the one you just can’t quite let go of—with us on social or by email. And hey, don’t forget your tin foil hat on the way out. ;)
No comments yet. Be the first to say something!